View Full Version : Is this too much to get a point accross?


ETHubby & 2 Kids
12-15-2005, 12:28 PM
By DAVID B. CARUSO, Associated Press Writer
Wed Dec 14, 2:35 PM ET



NEW YORK - It's usually easy to tell where a person stands in the culture wars, but whose side is someone on when his Christmas decor is a blood-spattered Santa Claus holding a severed head?
Joel Krupnik and Mildred Castellanos decked the front of their Manhattan mansion this year with a scene that includes a knife-wielding 5-foot-tall St. Nick and a tree full of decapitated Barbie dolls. Hidden partly behind a tree, the merry old elf grasps a disembodied doll's head with fake blood streaming from its eye sockets.
In a telephone interview Wednesday, Krupnik explained that his family thought it would be a fun way to make a comment about the commercialization and secularization of Christmas.
"It is a religious holiday, but they have turned it into a business. And it shouldn't be," he said. "We didn't put it up to offend anybody. It was just something that came out of our imagination."
More than a few people passing by the brownstone were a little puzzled about the message behind the massacre. There were a few signs the macabre theme is a year-round thing — the facade of the building was covered with leering gargoyles. A statue of Death, hooded and grim-looking, stood outside.
Peter Nardoza, 81, of Manhattan, shook his head and chuckled.
"Sick, sick, sick," he said. "What kind of a world is this that we live in?"
Ronnie Santiago, a deliveryman on his route, speculated that something bad must have happened once to the homeowner at Christmas. A few spectators wondered whether the campy gore would bother children.
The family is far from the only one making an editorial comment this year on how Americans celebrate Christmas, although it may be the only one doing it by depicting Santa Claus as a killer.
Pope Benedict XVI complained this week that Christmas festivities have been "subjected to a sort of commercial pollution." Christian conservatives have launched campaigns to reintroduce a religious component to Christmastime decor in schools and public squares, chiding even President Bush this year for sending out cards wishing supporters a happy "holiday season."
But despite the home's gruesome exterior, some visitors appreciated it.
Bucky Turco, 31, of Manhattan, said the display captured how he felt when watching someone costumed as SpongeBob SquarePants promote products at Rockefeller Center.
"This is brilliant," said Turco.
Walter Garofalo, a musician from Brooklyn who wandered by wearing a black bandanna covered in skulls, was awe-struck.
"I wonder if these people would let me use this as our next album cover," he said. "It's perfect!"



Ok so yeah Christmas has gone comericial. But to add violence to get a point accross is to me going over board

Becca
12-15-2005, 12:45 PM
I think there are better ways to make their point. I would be worried about the kids seeing it - it's a good point that he's trying to make, but I really hate it when people try to make a point by doing something that makes no sense whatsoever in relation to the point they're attempting to make. (how's that for a runon sentence?) Dumbasses.

harrisonsdream
12-15-2005, 01:12 PM
i think that people should leave the name christmas alone...if you don't celebrate christmas or you don't like it just ignore it damnit

Becca
12-15-2005, 01:34 PM
His point wasn't that he didn't like Christmas. If you read the entire article, you'll see that the point he was trying to make was that Christmas has become to commercial and secularized (is that a word, I wonder?). Your response to his display completely makes MY point for me :lmao

KevzQueen
12-15-2005, 03:34 PM
that's crazy. poor kids when they see that.

Me&D
12-16-2005, 02:37 PM
I think it's great. I'm not very religious but I do think this holiday has become nothing so much as an oppportunity for marketers to make people part with more and more of their money each year.

What these people did is so much more creative than just putting out a sign saying "stop the commercialization of christmas" or writing a letter to the editor. I appreciate the aritistic aspect of it.

Also, it's one of those "only in NY" moments that, if you live here, makes you kinda glad you do, even if just shake your head in bewilderment.